General Inquiry - Student Questions FAQ
This section answers questions pertaining to issues regarding public school districts.
- Is a parent entitled to a copy of the scoring sheets from her daughter's cheerleading tryouts at her high school?
- At what age may a student drop out of school?
- What are the guidelines for mandatory drug testing of all students entering a public school?
- Can a teacher let students grade each other's papers?
- My child has gone by his middle name during his time in school. The school district has changed his name on his records to his first name on his birth certificate. Can they do this?
- What are the standards on releasing privacy act information such as social security number, telephone number, address, over the telephone to another agency?
- Is a pregnant student still allowed to attend public schools?
- Can a school district withhold a student's report card because he/she owes a fine?
- Can a school district require a social security number as their student identification number?
- Does Chapter 37 have specific guidelines for student placement in ISS (In-School Suspension)?
- Can corporal punishment be applied without notification to the parents?
- Who is responsible for maintaining the student's permanent record?
1. Is a parent entitled to a copy of the scoring sheets from her daughter's cheerleading tryouts at her high school?
A parent is entitled to a copy of all "education records" that are directly related to a student and maintained by a public school under the Family Education Rights and Privacy Act ("FERPA"). Those regulations are in Chapter 99 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations. What it means to be an "education record" under FERPA is less clear since the US Supreme Court's decision this year in the peer grading case (the tests being graded were not found to be "student records"). State law also recognized parental access to "student records" under our Public Information Act (Section 552.114, Texas Government Code and Section 26.004, Texas Education Code).
If a record exists that is directly related to a particular student, that student's parents generally have a right to a copy of the record, subject to a very few health and safety exceptions (criminal investigations, etc.) and subject to protecting confidential information about other students. [top]
2. At what age may a student drop out of school?
A child who is under 18 years of age is required to attend public school. There are several exemptions from this requirement. A primary exemption is for students who are enrolled in a private or parochial school, including a home school. Another primary exemption applies to students who are at least 17 years of age and are either enrolled in a GED (high school equivalency) program or have received either a high school diploma or a GED certificate. The statutes stating the compulsory ages of attendance and the exemptions from attendance are Sections 25.085 and 25.086 of the Texas Education Code. If a child is required to attend school and fails to do so, criminal charges may be brought against the parent under Section 25.093 or against the student under Section 25.094. The offense is a Class C mindemeanor. There is some information on this topic in the attendance section of the Administrator's Letter. [top]
3. What are the guidelines for mandatory drug testing of all students entering a public school?
There are no state guidelines. This issue has been litigated as a constitutional challenge to drug testing programs in public schools. While a number of cases have been decided or are on appeal, about all one can definitively say is that random testing of student athletes is constitutional, since that has been decided by the U.S. Supreme Court. Beyond that, there is no definitive guidance. [top]
4. Can a teacher let students grade each other's papers?
In Owasso Independent School District No. I-011 v. Falvo, decided February 9, 2002, the United States Supreme Court held that having students grade each other's papers and call out the grades does not violate FERPA, the federal confidentiality statute. The court did not address whether a grade on an individual assignment is a protected "education record" after it is recorded in the teacher's grade book. [top]
5. My child has gone by his middle name during his time in school. The school district has changed his name on his records to his first name on his birth certificate. Can they do this?
House Bill 1276 enacted by the Legislature this year (2001) added Section 25.0021 to the Education Code that requires a student to be identified by either the name on the birth certificate or a court order changing the student's name. The only way to identify a student by a different name would be to have his name legally changed. [top]
6. What are the standards on releasing privacy act information such as social security number, telephone number, address, over the telephone to another agency?
Personal information about students is governed by the Federal law Family Education Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). Name, address and phone number can often be given out as "directory" information under that statute, though social security numbers should not be given out. There are provisions in the FERPA regulations allowing information to be shared with certain educational oversight agencies, such as TEA or the U.S. Department of Education (DOE), as well as other exceptions. The regulations (Chapter 99 of Title 34 of the US Code of Federal Regulations) are fairly readable and on the US DOE website. [top]
Information about public employees is generally public, except that Section 552.024 of the Texas Government Code requires a process by which an employee be given 14 days to choose not to have address, phone number, social security number and family information disclosed.
There is no real distinction to releasing information over the telephone; either it has been released or not released.
The links to FERPA and the DOE can be found in the Links to Related Sites page of the Legal Services web page. [top]
7. Is a pregnant student still allowed to attend public schools?
A student is entitled to enroll in Texas public schools based on residency in the district, regardless of pregnancy. More information can be found in the agency letter on admissions. Federal law also prohibits discrimination in an educational program on the basis of pregnancy. [top]
8. Can a school district withhold a student's report card because he/she owes a fine?
The only authorization to withhold records is Section 31.104(d) of the Texas Education Code, which allows withholding an official transcript (only) because of failure to pay for a lost textbook. Even then, the district may not withhold the report card indefinitely. Under Section 28.022 of the Education Code, a school district must give the parent written notice of the student's perfomance in each class of subject at least once every 12 weeks. The district must comply with Section 28.022 regardless of non-payment of fines. [top]
9. Can a school district require a social security number as their student identification number?
A social security number (SSN) is generally used to report students in the state system. Most student-identifiable information (including SSN) are protected as confidential by state and federal law. A student who does not have a social security number or whose parents do not wish to disclose it will be assigned a state-issued number. While the preference is to use the SSN (it is easier to track students through a 13 year academic program that may involve a number of transfers), refusing to provide it is not a basis for refusing to enroll an eligible student. [top]
10. Does Chapter 37 have specific guidelines for student placement in ISS (In-School Suspension)?
In-school suspension is implicitly recognized by reference in Texas Eduction Code Section 37.002 (c), but is not regulated by the state. It's up to local policy. [top]
11. Can corporal punishment be applied without notification to the parents?
Each school district has a Student Code of Conduct that describes the policy decisions that the district's board has made regarding student discipline. While there are state minimums under Chapter 37 of the Texas Education Code, a District is generally free to determine what punishments it will utilize. [top]
12. Who is responsible for maintaining the student's permanent record?
School districts are required to keep some student records permanently. Which personnel, in the district, are responsible for maintaining the records is determined locally. A school district retains student records for a period of time determined by their local record retention plan, but some retention periods are determined by schedules published by the State Library and Archives Commission. [top]